The assumption so many people forget to test


Dear you (I’m giving up on automated personalisation),

I’m a physicist, even though I’m a very ex-physicist. But one of the things that has stuck with me since doing my PhD is the value of experiments. The importance of experiments came back when I was running our digital agency. Back in the heyday of the “Lean Startup”, experiments were all the rage when starting a business.

Validate your assumptions!

That was the mantra.

For those of you who aren’t familiar with the approach, it was all about minimising risk. Why spend months of your life and thousands of your hard-earned (or borrowed) poundingtons and build something that will eventually flop because you didn’t check one vital piece of information.

One of our clients back in our agency days had the innovative idea of making it easier for people to donate to charity as a present for someone rather than give them an actual present. If you’re anything like me you’d be pretty disappointed with that kind of present but that’s the kind of selfish guy I am… 😜

Anyway, the idea seemed sound (or else we wouldn’t have taken on the project) and there were a lot of amazing charities and good causes that could use his help. Purpose-driven startup success… here we come!

However, there was one (quite big) wrinkle, the guy hadn’t asked charities whether they could accept money in the way he was proposing. He’d made a simple (yet massive) assumption that receiving money from anonymous donors via some opaque payment mechanism wouldn’t be an issue. They were getting money, right..?!?

Apparently not.

And so, £30k and 6 months later, the project tanked.

That was an expensive lesson in the importance of testing your assumptions.

But there's another assumption I see people making when starting businesses. One that's less obvious, but potentially just as costly.

Do I actually want to do the work required to make this idea successful?

Not just the outcome. The actual day-to-day work.

Too many people start with an idea and work from the outside in. Maybe they say, I need to make X amount of money or I want to reach Y amount of people. They see a problem in the world and they feel connected to it in some way and they find a cunning idea to solve that problem.

But they don’t actually consider whether making their cunning idea work will actually drain them or energise them.

I’ve seen it so many times. If you’re not really excited by the process of building your business, there’s a good chance you’ll quit along the way. You’ll either feel like you’re not making fast enough progress, or you’ll be swayed by all the “naysayers” (aka people who’re too scared to do their own thing, or just don’t understand your idea).

On Friday, someone at Ideas Café talked about his ambition to reach 10,000 people with his free course.

But he hated social media and didn't want to spend his time promoting it. He was excited by the impact he wanted to create. But was he excited by the work required to get there?

And could he have tested that assumption earlier?

We spend so much time measuring whether our ideas are viable that we forget to ask whether they're desirable. Not just for our customers, but for ourselves.

Does the work excite or energise you?

Does it diminish or expand you?

Is it something you'd happily spend your days doing?

Because building a successful business that you don't enjoy running isn't really success. It's just another job you've created for yourself.

Now, I know that doing all that introspective work about getting clarity about what you want and what energises you can feel like a black hole that will suck away all your time.

But it doesn’t have to be.

Even just making an “imperfect start” (like with any good idea) can help.

So, before you hit 2027 chasing goals that leave you feeling empty, check out our Excite Strategy Toolkit. I hope the simple steps, scaffolding, and guidance will help you feel your way forward and avoid you wasting time and money on work that isn’t really yours to do.

Big love,

Carlos


The Happy Startup School

People at a turning point in their work. You’ve built something that works, but it no longer feels right. Expect thoughtful prompts, honest reflections, and practical ways to realign your work with who you are now, and move forward with clarity and courage.

Read more from The Happy Startup School

Hello, It’s November already. Halloween has just passed and the nights are getting dark here in Brighton. This time of year always reminds me of days playing Dungeons and Dragons. One particular evening Jonathan Nightingale was the Dungeon Master. He was a lot older than us. He lived down the road with his bohemian family. He knew how to create an atmosphere. We were in my parents’ shed in suburban West London, with just a candle to light the game. I was excited as my wizard, Cadelin...

Hi Reader, Last week I asked a group of guys to gather some random objects and arrange them on a table to help them do some self-reflection. It’s not your typical Zoom workshop. We were exploring four archetypes: the King, Warrior, Magician and Lover. The idea was to choose an object to represent themselves, then another for each archetype. They then arranged these objects to reflect how these different parts of themselves were showing up in their lives. And then rearranged them to represent...

Dear Reader, There’s no shortage of people telling us how to do things. How to grow a business. How to find customers. How to build an audience. How to be more productive. How to live a better life. And now, with AI, we have access to more knowledge than ever before. But there’s a problem. Knowing what to do doesn’t mean we’ll actually do it. And sometimes, the thing stopping us has very little to do with what we know. Take writing on LinkedIn, for example. There are endless experts offering...